Whenever I type the word “bananas”, I hear a certain Gwen Stefani song in my head… This post is going to be painful to type!
I just wanted to put up a quick post on one of Americans’ favorite fruits. According to the USDA, bananas are the most consumed fruit in the United States, accounting for 25% of fresh fruit consumption. Bananas are rich in potassium, magnesium, and manganese, and while some who embrace a low-carb lifestyle may find fault with them, they are without doubt a whole, real, food. While our modern domesticated varieties are very different from wild bananas (and no, the shape of the banana is NOT proof of creationism!), bananas can be part of a healthy diet for most people. Bananas are a staple of many traditional diets, and their leaves are also used for cooking in many cultures.
In America, the word banana is synonymous with the Cavendish banana, but this is certainly not the only variety and many argue it is not the best. “Best” is, of course, subjective. Choosing a “best” banana is like choosing a best apple*. Seasonality and freshness matter, as does personal preference.
Variety makes life interesting. Genetic variation is necessary for evolution. Food variation makes out diet more interesting (and broadens our nutrient intake while minimizing exposure to potential toxins). Over the past year or so, I’ve made it my goal to try as many varieties of banana as I can find- so far I’m doing pretty well.
Cavendish bananas (a triploid variant of Musa acuminata) can be found just about anywhere. Grocery stores, cafeterias, and many gas stations have these ubiquitous yellow fruit on offer year round.
At my local grocery store I can usually find other Musa varieties. Next to a small selection of yucca, aloe, and other somewhat “exotic” offerings I can almost always find plantains (a hybrid between Musa acuminata and Musa balbisiana). They usually have green plantains, sometimes yellow, and occasionally brown. The color varies with ripeness. Green plantains are the least ripe and are not sweet, while yellow- or even better, dark brown- plantains are sweet. Plantains are best eaten cooked. (Personally I love to fry them up in coconut oil. The greens are great with a squeeze of lime, some chile, and salt, while the sweeter fruits are good plain or with a shake of cinnamon or cocoa.)
Occasionally my local supermarket has Niño bananas ( a diploid variant of Musa acuminata known by a number of other names), and I can almost always find these at the Asian supermarket I like to visit. I find that these small bananas have a similar taste, though slightly different texture, than Cavendish bananas.
At my favorite Asian supermarket I’ve also found Burro bananas, which (at least to me) seem like a hybrid between plantains and Cavendish. It can be eaten cooked or raw. To me they have a slightly tart, almost lemony, flavor when eaten fresh. They have a distinct shape- shorter than Cavendish and very angular.
This weekend, I found yet another type of banana to add to my list. I was visiting a friend on Long Island and took a trip through an ethnic supermarket that caters to the local Hispanic population. Like so many ethnic supermarkets, this store had a fabulous produce section- with a great variety of fruits & vegetables, all really fresh and reasonably priced. The meat department was also extensive, with lots of interesting cuts, including goat! (A friend and I were recently bemoaning the fact that you can rarely find goat in the US- I’ve only ever had it when my family bought whole animals from a local farmer).
At the store on Long Island I finally came across Red bananas (another triploid variant of Musa acuminata). As the name suggests, this variety is a dark red, almost purple. Otherwise, it looks like a slightly smaller Cavendish. I picked up a couple but I haven’t tried them yet as I don’t think they’re quite ripe.

The variety of different bananas I picked up. From left to right: Niños, Reds, Cavendish, and plantains.
I only have to find one more type of banana to knock off every variety on this list, and I will continue to keep my eyes open for other, unusual varieties. Some of my family members have tried Manzano bananas while visiting Hawaii, and as the name promises, they do taste a bit like apples (Manzano is spanish for apple).
Actually, it looks like Hawaii has many interesting types of bananas, and I’m in desperate need of some sunshine and relaxation… looks like it’s time to go look at plane tickets to Hawaii!!
I wish… I start an EMS elective tomorrow. I’m looking forward to working with first responders as we pick up and transport patients to our University Hospital. From all reports, this is an exciting elective!
*When it comes to apples, GoldRush are, without a doubt, my favorite, but the “best” apple on any given day depends on what is fresh, what is in season, and what you’re in the mood for!
You left out the the Republican variety!
Much more expensive on the per pound basis than any of the other types!
Matoke (steamed green banana) is big in Uganda. At first, some people told me it was plantain, but the taste was just not as pleasing as the plantains I’ve had in the past. You can see a plateful on the bottom right of this pic:
The only time I see plantains here is “gonja”, when they take yellow plantains, peel them, and roast over charcoal. So good! I think I see a few boiled ones, too, still unpeeled.
(roasted)
In Nicaragua, platanos are soooo delicious, somewhat like you described. Green platanos were chopped into 1 inch cylinders, fried on each side, flattened, and refried (tostones), or yellow/black platanos were sliced somewhat diagonally and lightly friend on each side (maduros). Ah, I miss it! This was all done in vegetable oils, but I think they use coconut oil on the eastern “Caribbean” coast of Nicaragua.
I do remember a soup in Nica that was made with very unripe green bananas. They needed to be peeled with a knife, and I think you had to cover your hands in oil to save them from the peel juice.
In both countries, raw yellow bananas (those niños, but also Cavendish-looking types) are common. They taste better in these countries. It’s hard to describe… not “sweeter”, but just a stronger banana/fruit flavor, very rich.
Those roasted plantains look delicious!
Yes- I generally crush my plantains when I fry them making them into tostones. This weekend I made them for a friend and she was impressed how easy they were, and how delicious (especially with a bit of guacamole and lime!
Interesting you mention about peeling them and the peel juice… I’ve never had difficulty peeling plantains until this weekend. This batch were really difficult to peel and my hands felt very grainy afterwards- it was hard to get them clean. I thought they might just be a little less ripe than I’m used to, but I wonder if it’s a different type.
Thanks for all the info on bananas from your experiences around the world!
Okay, I was with you until the apples…Empire apples are definitely the best, unless I need a vehicle to carry blue cheese to my mouth and then only Granny Smiths will do!
I will say that I never knew there were so many types of bananas to be had. I will have to look around some of the asian markets for an interesting treat. Thanks for the post.
Empires are great and all, but as GoldRush are some of the last apples to rippen, I generally just feel like I’m spinning my wheels and whetting my appetite with other varieties until GoldRush are picked. They are incredibly dense and tart, great for eating whole (though probably not if you have dentures!) and also an excellent mechanism for blue cheese transportation! They also store really well, so you can buy a big box in the fall and have tasty local apples throughout the winter!
Good luck on your quest to try different bananas- let me know if you find any new types!
Here in Northern parts of NZ Bananas grow “wild” in many gardens (someone had to have planted them once, but they keep on going forever), including ours. The fruit, which is plentiful in years with good summers, is short and fat, starchy and filling, not very sweet. About the size of the reds in the picture, but green/yellow. When unripe it looks more like the wild banana.
Interesting! I wonder if they’re more closely related to the burro banana (which to me are more similar in size and shape to the wild variety) http://www.friedas.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/BurroBanana_03.jpg
Have you tried cooking them?
Here in the states (at least in the part where I live), you frequently find old apple trees… They’re probably not wild as much as they’re forgotten from generations past. It’s funny to me that people will sometimes buy apples for cooking when they have perfectly acceptable fruit in their own back yard!
[…] isn’t the same as the food our ancestors gathered (I’ll refer you back to the post I did on bananas- check out the difference between the wild and the domesticated fruit), but what you pick yourself […]